Directory Submissions are not for SEO!
I am sick and tired, tired and sick of potential clients asking me how many directories I will submit their site to. “But in this proposal, they said directory submissions are essential!” For most of us in the SEO world, this beast has been dead and buried for some time, but how do we get the word out that directory submissions are no longer the super highway to link building success? (as if they ever really were) I suggest that every SEO company include a blog post on this very subject. It would be great to be able to throw down 15 links to all the major agencies talking about the myth of directory submissions boosting your link juice.
So obviously this will serve as my post. When considering all of the wonderful things that actually create valuable link juice, it is easy to see that most directories have none of these things.
1. Content – It is the king, and directories often have very little of it. There might be a few 200 word blurbs, but as far as valuable or entertaining content creation on a regular basis, directories are extremely lacking.
2. Indexing (with verified sitemap) – Upon closer look, you might realize that many of the interior pages of directories are not even indexed in major search engines. In fact, you might be submitting to be included on a page that does not even exist to Google, Yahoo, or MSN. (might want to check on that)
3. Relevance – Are these directories really relevant to your industry? When your website is submitted to hundreds, if not thousands, of directories, how do you know the relevance of those directories? Any time you talk about doing a hundred or more things at one time I start to get a bit nervous.
4. Incoming Links – Who links to a directory? Seriously, most directories have very little link flow themselves, which is why their PageRank usually matches. So why does it make sense that a link from a directory with no PageRank is valuable link juice?
5. Outgoing Links – How many sites are these directories linking out to? Any PageRank that a directory might have attained is then immediately dispersed to the several hundred sites in their listings, giving a client’s website a very small piece of the pie.
Now with that said, there are a couple of directories that can be useful for referral traffic, such as Yahoo Directory and Business.com, and even beyond those, some niche directories have their place. However, these are not the type of directory submissions SEO companies are peddling. Clients can easily submit their websites to these directories themselves, and each should be individually considered. Even if an SEO company claims to manually submit to directories, you must again consider all of the factors listed above and seriously debate the value of submitting to any directories, especially if your goal is search engine optimization. I think you will find that 95% of the time the link juice just is not there.
About the Author: Peter Hamilton is the Project Manager in charge of the Seattle office of ArteWorks SEO. His interest and experience in Internet marketing is largely focused on the social media optimization and multi-media facets of exposure. To learn more about this search engine optimization company, visit www.arteworks.biz.
So obviously this will serve as my post. When considering all of the wonderful things that actually create valuable link juice, it is easy to see that most directories have none of these things.
1. Content – It is the king, and directories often have very little of it. There might be a few 200 word blurbs, but as far as valuable or entertaining content creation on a regular basis, directories are extremely lacking.
2. Indexing (with verified sitemap) – Upon closer look, you might realize that many of the interior pages of directories are not even indexed in major search engines. In fact, you might be submitting to be included on a page that does not even exist to Google, Yahoo, or MSN. (might want to check on that)
3. Relevance – Are these directories really relevant to your industry? When your website is submitted to hundreds, if not thousands, of directories, how do you know the relevance of those directories? Any time you talk about doing a hundred or more things at one time I start to get a bit nervous.
4. Incoming Links – Who links to a directory? Seriously, most directories have very little link flow themselves, which is why their PageRank usually matches. So why does it make sense that a link from a directory with no PageRank is valuable link juice?
5. Outgoing Links – How many sites are these directories linking out to? Any PageRank that a directory might have attained is then immediately dispersed to the several hundred sites in their listings, giving a client’s website a very small piece of the pie.
Now with that said, there are a couple of directories that can be useful for referral traffic, such as Yahoo Directory and Business.com, and even beyond those, some niche directories have their place. However, these are not the type of directory submissions SEO companies are peddling. Clients can easily submit their websites to these directories themselves, and each should be individually considered. Even if an SEO company claims to manually submit to directories, you must again consider all of the factors listed above and seriously debate the value of submitting to any directories, especially if your goal is search engine optimization. I think you will find that 95% of the time the link juice just is not there.
About the Author: Peter Hamilton is the Project Manager in charge of the Seattle office of ArteWorks SEO. His interest and experience in Internet marketing is largely focused on the social media optimization and multi-media facets of exposure. To learn more about this search engine optimization company, visit www.arteworks.biz.
Labels: automated directory submissions, directory submissions, internet marketing, seo companies, seo submissions
posted by Peter Hamilton - Arteworks SEO at
10:41 AM
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Thanks for your Comment!