Paid Links: The Holy War of SEO
Yet another conflict arose at this year’s SMX Advanced here in Seattle, WA. Just a short jaunt from my home in Seattle, I was pleased to have a bit of controversy in my own backyard. Jay Young, of Link Fish Media stepped up to the “Blow Your Mind Link Building Techniques” session, intending to do just that. Among other “brass balls” techniques, Jay is a hearty advocate of Paid Links, suggesting that it is a perfectly legitimate marketing method and that SEO’s and small businesses should not be afraid of Google’s iron fist.
The Google Fist himself, Matt Cutts, later took the stage in a session called “You and a Session with Matt Cutts,” in which he proceeded to morally challenge the likes of Jay Young by questioning who wants to be in an industry like that. Unfortunately for Matt, it seems we are already very much in an industry like that, and I don’t know about you, but my arm was never twisted. To me it is almost like asking who would want to live in a world where money equaled power or sex sells products. The fact of the matter is that money does produce success, especially in marketing. Saying it is not fair for a company to purchase links for the sake of their online visibility is like saying it isn’t fair that one restaurant has a great location and atmosphere and therefore gets all of the traffic, while the taco shack on the corner has much better food (not a perfect analogy I know, but you get the point). In a perfect world the Internet, and all search engines associated with it, would remain unbiased and reflect only the best, most relevant content. But even then we have a problem. The “best” is always subjective, and the “most relevant” content is certainly an opinion. Historically, we have always been told what is best by the government or the church, but mainly by big business. Themz the cold hard facts of life, and it will be no different for the Internet, unfortunately.
So while it may seem unjust or shallow, you must ask yourself the question, “do I want to play the game?” Perhaps this whole world of business is just too cutthroat, too self seeking, and too unfair. If that is the case, any type of marketing or profit seeking venture is probably not the best place for you. May I remind everyone that all of the major engines make a great deal of their profits directly from link sales. Anyone paying for Adword links? How are search engines exempt? Besides, buying and selling links can also produce a healthy dose of commerce and help people find already trusted companies who have achieved great financial success. In a funny way, bought links can actually produce better content for the web. Just as paid advertisement has allowed for the creation of some of the world’s greatest news stations, films, and television shows, so can link selling provide a great incentive for producing excellent web content.
Officially, ArteWorks SEO does not participate in link buying or selling, but I am not going to judge another for participating in what seems to me to be a perfectly natural way of doing business. Though I love the idea of a pure search engine that only brings me the best content and a world where all people help others before themselves, I am faced with the reality that not everyone is going to promote my business for me or give me the shirt off their back. I have to agree with Jay that this is marketing, not morality. The day I see Yahoo pages ranking in the top results on Google, and visa versa, perhaps I will give this some more thought. For now, I will call it a difference in ethical opinion in which both sides have their flaws.
About the Author: Peter Hamilton is the Project Manager in charge of the Seattle office of ArteWorks SEO. His interest and experience in Internet marketing is largely focused on the social media and multi-media facets of exposure. To learn more about this search engine optimization company, visit www.arteworks.biz.
The Google Fist himself, Matt Cutts, later took the stage in a session called “You and a Session with Matt Cutts,” in which he proceeded to morally challenge the likes of Jay Young by questioning who wants to be in an industry like that. Unfortunately for Matt, it seems we are already very much in an industry like that, and I don’t know about you, but my arm was never twisted. To me it is almost like asking who would want to live in a world where money equaled power or sex sells products. The fact of the matter is that money does produce success, especially in marketing. Saying it is not fair for a company to purchase links for the sake of their online visibility is like saying it isn’t fair that one restaurant has a great location and atmosphere and therefore gets all of the traffic, while the taco shack on the corner has much better food (not a perfect analogy I know, but you get the point). In a perfect world the Internet, and all search engines associated with it, would remain unbiased and reflect only the best, most relevant content. But even then we have a problem. The “best” is always subjective, and the “most relevant” content is certainly an opinion. Historically, we have always been told what is best by the government or the church, but mainly by big business. Themz the cold hard facts of life, and it will be no different for the Internet, unfortunately.
So while it may seem unjust or shallow, you must ask yourself the question, “do I want to play the game?” Perhaps this whole world of business is just too cutthroat, too self seeking, and too unfair. If that is the case, any type of marketing or profit seeking venture is probably not the best place for you. May I remind everyone that all of the major engines make a great deal of their profits directly from link sales. Anyone paying for Adword links? How are search engines exempt? Besides, buying and selling links can also produce a healthy dose of commerce and help people find already trusted companies who have achieved great financial success. In a funny way, bought links can actually produce better content for the web. Just as paid advertisement has allowed for the creation of some of the world’s greatest news stations, films, and television shows, so can link selling provide a great incentive for producing excellent web content.
Officially, ArteWorks SEO does not participate in link buying or selling, but I am not going to judge another for participating in what seems to me to be a perfectly natural way of doing business. Though I love the idea of a pure search engine that only brings me the best content and a world where all people help others before themselves, I am faced with the reality that not everyone is going to promote my business for me or give me the shirt off their back. I have to agree with Jay that this is marketing, not morality. The day I see Yahoo pages ranking in the top results on Google, and visa versa, perhaps I will give this some more thought. For now, I will call it a difference in ethical opinion in which both sides have their flaws.
About the Author: Peter Hamilton is the Project Manager in charge of the Seattle office of ArteWorks SEO. His interest and experience in Internet marketing is largely focused on the social media and multi-media facets of exposure. To learn more about this search engine optimization company, visit www.arteworks.biz.
Labels: internet marketing, paid links, seo
posted by Peter Hamilton - Arteworks SEO at
4:20 PM
|
0 Comments
Links to this post
